How the Heart Association Ranked 10 Popular Diets
The Lowcountry Plate · Episode 1 · 10 min
Listen to episode 1 (audio only)
0:00 / 10:51
Episode Description
The American Heart Association scored 10 popular diets against its advice for a healthy heart. DASH came out on top and keto at the bottom. Here is what the tiers mean and how a Lowcountry plate fits.
Transcript
Bella: Thanks for joining us. You're listening to The Lowcountry Plate. This episode is sponsored by Hope Medical Associates, part of Hope Health Network, a group of medical practices that provide care to South Carolinians statewide. Today we're in the Lowcountry.
Bella: I'm Bella, and this is episode 1. I'm going to quickly play our disclaimers, and then we'll get started!
Recorded disclaimer: This show is for entertainment, education and general information only. It's not medical advice, and listening doesn't make you a patient. Our hosts and guests are not real people, medical doctors or healthcare providers. We do our best, but we can be wrong, and our content can have errors and omissions. Talk with a licensed medical provider in your state before you make any decisions about your health or medical care.
Bella: In an emergency, call 911. In a crisis, call or text 988.
Bella: Joining me today is Michael, from our digital entertainment team. Welcome, Michael!
Michael: Good to be here, Bella. How's your week going?
Bella: Busy, but good. I finally cleared my whole to-do list, which never happens.
Michael: Well, don't tell anybody, or they'll hand you a longer one.
Bella: So, what's on the plate today?
Michael: Today we're talking about How the Heart Association Ranked 10 Popular Diets.
Bella: Well, we're excited to get your thoughts on this important topic, Michael.
Bella: Let's dig into how the Heart Association ranked 10 popular diets. New diets show up every January. So I'm glad someone finally graded them. Who did the grading?
Michael: The American Heart Association did. In 2023, an expert panel scored 10 popular ways of eating. They checked each one against the group's own advice for a healthy heart.
Bella: So it's like a report card for diets.
Michael: That's a good way to put it. Scores ran from 100 at the top down to 31 at the bottom.
Bella: Before we get to the winners, what were they grading on? What does a good score need?
Michael: The advice asks for lots of vegetables and fruit. It asks for whole grains. It asks for protein that comes mostly from plants and fish. It favors liquid plant oils, like olive oil. And it asks for less added sugar, salt and alcohol.
Bella: That list sounds a lot like what my grandmother told me. Eat your greens and go easy on the sweets.
Michael: She was ahead of her time. The panel also looked at how processed the food is. Foods closer to how they grow scored better.
Bella: Now, one thing I want to be clear on. Did they put people on these diets and test them?
Michael: No. And that's an important point. The scores show how closely each diet matches the advice. They are not results from a new trial.
Bella: So it's a grade for the plan on paper, not a weigh-in.
Michael: Right. It doesn't tell you how much weight anyone lost. It tells you how well the plan lines up with heart-healthy eating.
Bella: Okay. Drumroll, please. Who came out on top?
Michael: Four diets made the top tier. They were DASH, Mediterranean, pescatarian and vegetarian.
Bella: Let's take those one at a time. What is DASH?
Michael: DASH stands for Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension. Hypertension is high blood pressure. DASH was the only plan to score a perfect 100.
Bella: A perfect score. What makes it so good?
Michael: It's full of vegetables, fruit and whole grains. It uses low-fat dairy, fish, poultry, beans and nuts. It cuts back on sweets and fatty meats. And it limits salt.
Bella: And the other three?
Michael: Mediterranean eating leans on plant oils, especially extra-virgin olive oil. Pescatarian means mostly plants, plus fish and seafood. Vegetarian here means no meat or fish, but eggs and dairy are allowed.
Bella: What do all four have in common?
Michael: They're rich in vegetables, fruit, whole grains and protein from plants. That's the core the panel liked.
Bella: So who's in the middle of the pack?
Michael: The second tier was vegan and low-fat eating. Both are built on vegetables, fruit, whole grains and beans, with little added sugar.
Bella: Vegan sounds healthy, though. Why not the top?
Michael: The statement says vegan eating is strict. That makes it hard for most people to keep up for a long time.
Bella: That makes sense. A plan you quit in March doesn't help much in June.
Michael: Exactly. The best plan is one you can stay with.
Bella: And the third tier?
Michael: That was very low-fat eating and low-carb eating. Each one has some strong points. But each one also cuts out whole food groups the advice wants you to eat.
Bella: Okay. Now the part everyone's waiting for. Who came in last?
Michael: Paleo scored 53. Keto, which is very low-carb, scored 31. Those two were the least like the heart advice.
Bella: Keto at the bottom. That will surprise some people. A lot of folks I know swear by it.
Michael: Some people do see changes in weight and blood sugar at first. But the statement points to a 2019 review. In that review, most of the gains were no longer clear after 12 months.
Bella: So it may help early, but it fades.
Michael: That's what that review found. And keto cuts back on fruit, whole grains and beans, which the advice wants more of.
Bella: What if someone listening has diabetes? I've heard low-carb can be helpful there.
Michael: That's a fair point, and expert groups don't all weigh it the same way. If you live with diabetes or high blood pressure, talk with your provider before a big change in how you eat.
Bella: Why is that?
Michael: Your provider knows your whole health picture. They can help you make a change like that safely.
Bella: Good. Now let's bring this home to the Lowcountry. Can I eat like a Charlestonian and still score well?
Michael: You can. Lowcountry cooking has a head start. Fresh local seafood fits the top-tier plans well.
Bella: I love hearing that. Give me some swaps. Start with shrimp and grits.
Michael: Keep the shrimp. Go lighter on the butter, cheese and sausage. Add greens or tomatoes on the side.
Bella: What about fried seafood? That's a hard one for me.
Michael: Try your fish and shrimp grilled, broiled or blackened. You keep the seafood and skip the fryer.
Bella: And a Lowcountry boil?
Michael: Load up on shrimp, corn and potatoes. Use less sausage. Serve a big salad with it.
Bella: Now, rice. Rice is a big part of how we eat here.
Michael: It is. Rice is at the heart of Lowcountry and Gullah Geechee cooking. Keep it. Just keep the portion to about a quarter of the plate. You can also try brown rice, or a mix of brown and white.
Bella: And Hoppin' John?
Michael: Hoppin' John is a great one. The field peas add fiber.
Bella: Collards?
Michael: Cook them with smoked turkey, onion, garlic or vinegar, instead of fatback. And go easy on the salt.
Bella: I know what's coming next. Sweet tea.
Michael: Try half-sweet first. Then try unsweet with lemon or mint. Every top-tier plan limits added sugar.
Bella: Half-sweet I can do. Unsweet might take me a while. Let's talk about salt for a minute. How much is too much?
Michael: The Food and Drug Administration says the Dietary Guidelines advise less than 2,300 milligrams of sodium a day.
Bella: Is that a lot?
Michael: Most Americans eat more than that, that agency says. Most of the sodium we eat comes from packaged and restaurant foods, not the salt shaker. So reading labels helps.
Bella: I've heard waist size matters too. Is that true?
Michael: It's a useful clue. The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute says fat around the waist raises the risk of heart disease and type 2 diabetes. The risk goes up with a waist over 40 inches for men, or over 35 inches for women.
Bella: So it's worth grabbing a tape measure.
Michael: It is. Or ask your provider to check it at your next visit.
Bella: If someone wants to start but feels a little overwhelmed, where should they begin?
Michael: Pick one swap this week. Maybe it's half-sweet tea. Maybe it's grilled fish instead of fried. Small steps add up.
Bella: And if they want more help?
Michael: Bring your questions to your next visit. Your provider can look at your blood pressure, your waist and your blood work. Then you can build a plan around the foods you enjoy.
Bella: Okay, before we wrap up. If people remember only a few things from today, what should they be?
Michael: First, the Heart Association put DASH, Mediterranean, pescatarian and vegetarian eating in its top tier. DASH scored a perfect 100.
Bella: Okay, good. What else?
Michael: Second, keto and paleo scored lowest. They cut out foods the heart advice wants you to eat.
Bella: Right. And one more?
Michael: Third, Lowcountry food fits. Keep the seafood, skip the fryer, watch the rice portion, and try half-sweet tea.
Bella: That's really helpful. Thanks for walking us through the rankings.
Michael: Thanks for having me. I think I'll go find some grilled shrimp.
Bella: The Lowcountry Plate comes from Hope Health Network Media. Today's episode is shared by Hope Medical Associates. Its office is in West Ashley, in Charleston.
Bella: One last reminder. This show is for entertainment, education and general information only. It's not medical advice. In an emergency, call 911. In a crisis, call or text 988.
Bella: You've been listening to episode 1 of The Lowcountry Plate, How the Heart Association Ranked 10 Popular Diets. Thanks for hanging out with us. See you next time!
About the show
The Palmetto Plate comes from Hope Health Network Media and is sponsored by Hope Health Network. Every season has episodes from the Lowcountry, the Midlands, the Pee Dee and the Upstate. This episode is part of The Lowcountry Plate.